Monday, April 11, 2005

Shut up! No, you shut up! No, you!

Caveat Lector: Can we shut up about Google a minute, please?

"We let our stupid bloody OPACs rot, acknowledging sheepishly that the last fifteen or so years’ worth of systems-design research has never made it into them, while we ask each other stupid bloody simplistic questions about whether Google is good or bad."

Thank you, Dorothea. I wish I were an information architect, or at least in a position to get our IT department to recognize that our "web catalog" is seriously weird. Daft split for author/title/subject versus keyword search is still there. Where is my eye supposed to light on this page? I can't really look at it as a new user, but I suspect it's the "all locations" box on the left. But even the words "all locations" confuse me a little.

Way too many words, says this text-based character. I hate having author for the default search (last name first idiot! this is a library page!). I am so much more likely to remember a title. Maybe that's just me? I've always hated the red instructions about boolean searches on the keyword side, but if we're going to do that, can't we tell the poor punters that it first name last for author and no initial articles on titles (with helpful examples?). Howabout layering a help screen one click under?

Why am I venting on you, poor reader? I was at a recent training on our new ILS, and they said the web catalog interface would not be changing. I almost wept. I'm pretty well known at MPOW for offering my opinions loudly. MPOW talks the talk about getting user feedback, but they don't do any usability testing at all, as far as I know. When I've been on tech task forces, I've been told our ideas would be implemented, and then seen them completely disregarded. I do not mean in this blog to air dirty laundry, or to just post negative thoughts "publicly". I want to make things better. I want to think about things. For me, to do that, I need to try them out in my mind and bring together other people's ideas and even get some feedback maybe. I don't have a good way to do that at work, so I'm muttering over it here.

No comments: