Free Range Librarian: Don't Agonize, Get Busy
Be sure to read the comments, or this will not make sense!
Once again, we have issues around librarianly "niceness" and groupthink. (Groupthink is a concept that was identified by Irving Janis that refers to faulty decision-making in a group. Groups experiencing groupthink do not consider all alternatives and they desire unanimity at the expense of quality decisions.
OK, librarians are never supposed to be scary. We are nice, pleasant, soft-spoken, welcoming. Unfortunately, I think this ends up effecting us negatively. Did I mention we are passive, powerless, lack respect, effeminate (worst of all)? We are not scary. "I am librarian, hear me roar"? It is to laugh.
There have been many discussions of the librarian stereotype and what we can do to change it. I think we need to address the fact that we can't be so bloody nice! I don't mean we should frighten small children (though spooky stories are practically required for middle school). But in my experience, frightening a city administration, or a library administration, can be absolutely necessary. I assume the same is true for academic libraries. The recent victory in Philadelphia did not come about due to the kindness of the mayor's heart. The staff, the librarians' union, and the friends groups, put the fear of god into the hearts of the mayor and the library administration. We said, if you are going to ream this system, you are not going to get that bright, shiny new monument to your egos (i.e., the new Central Library). Suddenly, the system did not need to be reamed. The part where the administration is claiming credit for this victory is nauseating.
Terrorize used to mean to scare mightily. Now, it almost means the actions of a Moslem. Or at least a towel head. Definitely has a racial meaning. Be afraid, be very afraid, of Arabs. That way, it doesn't matter when we kill 10,000 civilians. Oh, an actual definition of terrorism: the calculated use of violence (or threat of violence) against civilians in order to attain goals that are political or religious or ideological in nature; this is done through intimidation or coercion or instilling fear. The people who are terrorizing me are not Moslem.
Meanwhile, completely unrelated to librarianism, I can only hope Rick Santorum is feeling terrorized.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
I liked the remark about scaring small children. That could be a problem for an elementary school librarian! However, there is a mean librarian stereotype, as well. The librarian at the High School where my wife teaches has that reputation. She acts as if students mere touching of "her" books is an act of sacrilege. She is also notoriously unhelpful to faculty. When I was a school librarian, I considered it part of my job to fix audio visual equipment (replace bulbs in overhead projectors, hook up TVs and VCRs, hook up LCD projectors to laptops so the Princial won't look like a fool trying to do it himself). I also solicited staff for ideas on what I should buy with library funds. My wife's school librarian doesn't do any of that. She defines her job very precisely as "Guardian of the Books."
Librarian as gorgon is a stereotype I am familiar with (Sarah C., are you reading this?). They deserve to be shot, all of them. The darkest side of librarianship--coming between readers and what they want to read (age appropriate, legal, etc.). I think the gorgons also hide behind librarianly niceness--quick to suck up to anyone in power. Icy politeness as weapon, ya know?
I guess I'm trying for something where we put fear in everyone but our patrons, which includes faculty. Still excepting spooky story hours and Halloween booktalks.
I do not want to be mean. I want power. Are the two mutually inclusive? I don't think so, but I am not powerful.
Post a Comment