Philadelphia Daily News | 05/09/2005 | John Baer | Circulation drop? We can blame ourselves
In all I've read/seen/heard about the vanishing newspaper, this is
the first time I have heard a reporter linking it to dumb-dumb content: "a public better acquainted with the decisions of TV talent judge Simon Cowell than with those of William Rehnquist." Fabulous. Let's hear it for the tabloid!
Since the link above is only good for 7 days and may require registration, and the Inky owes me, and I think this may be fair use, here's the text:
John Baer | Circulation drop? We can blame ourselves
I'M READING, with interest and sorrow, about circulation declines at major newspapers, the steepest drop in nearly a decade.
Oh, USA Today is up. And the New York Times. But elsewhere? Washington Post, L.A. Times, Chicago Tribune, Boston Globe? All down. Philly's no exception. Both dailies dropped.
Experts blame the Internet, cable TV, scandals involving artificially inflated circulation numbers, and federal do-not-call regs cutting into telemarketers' selling subscriptions.
I, on the other hand, blame newspapers.
And, understand, I love newspapers, always have (my late father was a journalist before me). I love their power and timeliness and, on good days, their clarity.
But it feels to me newspapers are engaged in self-assisted suicide.
Here's why.
Round-the-clock media pay full attention to stories such as Georgia's runaway bride and Paula Abdul's alleged fling with a would-be "American Idol."
Newspapers shouldn't. Those stories and others as soft and inconsequential eat up space and resources - which is a shame.
By following ever-falling standards set by radio loudmouths and TV talkers with minimal if any journalistic background, newspapers squander their strength and risk their relevance.
Worse, they help create a public better acquainted with the decisions of TV talent judge Simon Cowell than with those of William Rehnquist.
Newspapers have the ability (and, I think, duty) to fully report issues directly impacting their readers and their regions. They should do so - with a focus far greater than on other "news."
And before you say, wait, the Daily News puts moms getting makeovers and sports stories on its front page, I know - we aren't always right. But we also do more than our share of at-your-doorstep stuff on schools, crime, mass transit and City Hall.
To that end, I'd like to speak at a J-school graduation. A top one.
The University of Missouri at Columbia, for example, graduates Friday. But photojournalist Bill Eppridge (National Geographic, Life, Sports Illustrated; best- known for his photo of a busboy cradling the head of Robert Kennedy moments after RFK was shot in 1968) is speaking. He graduated there in 1960, so I understand.
Columbia University in New York graduates next Wednesday. David Halberstam (author, journalist, Harvard grad) is speaking. He won a Pulitzer when he was 30. He's now in his 70s. Guess I'll have to wait.
And at the famed Medill School at Northwestern University, which graduates June 17, the speaker is Jack Fuller, president of Tribune Publishing. He's also a Yale lawyer. And he too won a Pulitzer. So I'm out of luck.
But if I were speaking to a J-class, I'd say something like this:
You are so lucky. You are entering the only profession protected by the Constitution. You are entering the only profession that regardless of your wealth, looks or personality, grants you a front- row seat to history. You, in fact, get to write the first draft of history.
You get to talk face-to-face with those shaping the world.
And for this you need no license, certificate, badge or continuing education. You don't even need to be particularly smart.
All you need do is ask questions. Show up and ask questions. And when important things happen, things that matter to people, you get to be right in the middle of them.
This is a privilege you cannot begin to appreciate today. Just know it comes with responsibility. The profession is at risk. You have to save it. You have to grab it and make sure no matter what else it does, it first does what it's supposed to: be an arbiter of justice, a watchdog of government, an honest broker of thoughtful dissent.
You've been trained to listen to all sides of a story, to do research, to check and double-check "facts," to get as close to the truth as possible.
Use your training every day. Don't be drawn to those you cover. Don't write for them. Write for your readers. Explain issues. Expose frauds. Guard against abuse of power, yours included.
And if you do these things, you will be valuable and necessary. And even if circulation drops, you will serve your profession and your readers in ways that can't be counted.
Send e-mail to baerj@phillynews.com
© 2005 Philadelphia Daily News and wire service sources. All Rights Reserved.
http://www.philly.com
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment